A Discussion on Petitio Principii

teleologyentropy replied to your post: A New Syllogism

Isn’t this begging the question though?

Begging the question is almost circular.  I don’t see where I stated B is true because B is true.  The syllogism contains three distinct objects:  coincidence, correlation and causation.  Stating that one doesn’t imply the other isn’t begging the question.  Begging the question involves asserting an assertion by using an item within the assertion.  Furthermore, it entails assuming a statement that requires proof without the required proof.  Perhaps you can be a little more specific.

  1. biblicalbelief said: The bit where you say the prayer didn’t do anything because prayers don’t do anything.. Is that not begging the question? (I literally have no idea, I just thought thats how BTQ worked)
  2. deconversionmovement posted this